CCBC Choices 2008: Best-of-the-year list at the long-running Cooperative Children's Book Center of the School of Education at the University of Wisconsin-Madison

2008 Great Graphic Novel for Teens as named by The Young Adult Library Services Association (YALSA), the fastest-growing division of the American Library Association (ALA)

2007 Russ Manning Most Promising Newcomer Award

Wizard: Best Adventure (“Indie Buzz”, #183)

Canada’s Metro News: Best Mini-series of 2006. (Metro News is the largest and fastest growing international newspaper in the world. Published in 94 major cities in 21 countries in 19 languages across Europe, North & South America and Asia.)

The Oklahoman: Placed in their “2006’s 10 best comic-book series”

IGN.com: Best Indie Book of the Year

Broken Frontier: David Petersen, Best Artist—Independent, Mouse Guard, Paper Screen Gem—Best Debut

Logan (West Virginia) Banner: Top 10 Comic of 2006

Guy LeCharles Gonzalez’s Comic Book Commentary: One of the Top 10 Comics of 2006

Brian Cronin at Comics Should Be Good: Best Fight of 2006. “It has to be the Mouse Guard versus the snake…”

ComicReaders.com: Derek Ash’s Top 10 List had Mouse Guard as the only book not from DC or Marvel

Broken Frontier honors Mouse Guard with numerous nominations for the 3rd Annual Broken Frontier Awards. Nominations include David Petersen (Best Artist—Independent and Best New Talent); Mouse Guard (Best Fantasy, Best Limited Series, and Best Debut). Five nominations in all! Congratulations David!

Comic Book Resources’ 2006 Corries: Favorite Limited/Mini Series

Ain’t It Cool News’s AICN Awards: Best Miniseries/Special/One-Shot